The Hypocrisy of Raising Money or Proclaiming Interest for The Haiti Disaster

The Nigerian Muse had an interesting take on the Haiti Disaster. I give them credit for pointing out the hypocrisy of one of the upper classes. However I believe it extends to everyone who claims they have an interest in the disaster without actually having one.

The only true humanitarian is one that recognizes that the state of anything can only be changed from the inside out. People must have the will to change internally in order for it to happen. You can perhaps provide them with the tools and knowledge, but if they do truly seek change they will seek these tools and knowledge from you without your having to initiate it. You should, however, make them available should they be sought.

Since larger society has abandoned this approach, when we are hit with devastation of a higher than normal nature, the reaction although useful to stem the immediate death does nothing for the long term sustainability of life. After the international spotlight leaves Haiti, it will be forgotten in the unfortunate squalor it has already endured for generations. Perhaps a native Haitian will soar above to lead their country without the strings of corruption restraining their flight, but then even the "superior" nations are corrupt themselves having only attained their superiority by the exploitation of their people's and other lesser nations like Haiti (and also the environment, another resource we feel capable of regulating for other less fortunate nations). Of exploitation, I am reminded of a certain trade agreement struck between the US and Haiti that allowed US rice farmers to sell their crops to Haitians at lower prices than the Haitian farmers. Ultimately the Haitian farmers were eliminated and the price of rice increased without any competition; all for some extra tax revenue and some generous donations to the officials that supported this agreement by the industry that benefitted.

But the hypocrisy of the wealthy elite (although the most obvious in main stream society due to the indoctrination of the media in every home and the idol worship that occurs through it) extends also to the rest of the classes that pronounce their concern for this foreign crisis. In the day to day shuffle of the lower and middle classes, how many have time to reflect on such international concerns as Haiti? Certainly very few were bothered about their previous status of worst place to live in the world. But I forget that many of these people simply regurgitate what they hear through the popular news outlets on cable anyway and rarely take a moment to reflect on the status of their existence.

One thing I would call to question in your article is the presence of the word mysticism. I hope that you do not stand on a soap box of superiority because the form of mysticism of who’s primary text you choose to quote involving a trinity of deities and a magical birth is no more valid or reasonable than that of Voodoo or Oprah-ism.

Jesus was a horse thief

There is an amusing biblical reference that, I don't care if you are a Christian, Muslim, Hindu, Pagan, Atheist, whatever. As an objective reader, there is no getting around the truth that indeed, Jesus was a horse thief.

http://www.flamewarrior.com/horsethief.htm

I would take this a step further, however, and point out that majority of the population had no education and were extremely susceptible to snake oil salesman and the like. The Roman Empire, wanting to maintain control over its people through government, made it their duty to eliminate and discredit these grass roots religions. Out of the thousands that developed, one happened to create a larger following than most. Does that mean it was the one "true" religion? Or just a more successful hoax.

I would go so far as to argue that the Roman leaders were trying to save the masses from these leeches on society by destroying them. Unfortunately they did not account for the martyr effect that this often produces. They should have, instead of killing them (wholly unnecessary in my opinion) simply required them to prove their powers in front of a live audience without the aid of any tools or people.

In modern society this would never fly. If some guy hot wired a car and was caught and sincerely believed that some deity told him to do it, he would either be judged as insane or put in jail anyway. That is exactly what happened 2000ish years ago but there was no GPS unit on the horse to catch the perp.